Nintendo, Intellivision, Arcade, Coins, Baseball, ANRI, Crossman, Collectables, Antiques Estate On-Line Auction

$300,000 baseball card? Ted Williams No.165 of the 1951 Bowman series PSA 10 Contender

Local pickup only in Sun Prairie, WI
$300,000 baseball card? Ted Williams No.165 of the 1951 Bowman series PSA 10 Contender

$300,000 baseball card? Ted Williams No.165 of the 1951 Bowman series PSA 10 Contender

This card was placed in a 1951 edition of Catcher in the Rye when new and it stayed there until placed in this holder. Many PSA 9's and lower cards have sold but there is no PSA 10 in the data base.. I have bought and sold sports cards for 45 years. I have looked at this card through the hard plastic case using a LED microscope. Looking at the corners, centering, colors, edges, etc. This card is right in every aspect.. I am not saying its a PSA 10 but if its not its a PSA 9.5 / 9.0 - A PSA 9 recently sold for $61,000 in the Spring Rarities Auction. I have examined that card and I feel this one is as good or better. If a PSA 10 no 165 1951 Ted Williams surfaces I feel the value would be in excess of $300,000. I am not making claims but have provided many pictures. If you want pics from under scope let me know
Also, I want to include the pics we're hard to take through plastic case. The light refraction , the case isn't that clear, etc
So why didn't I take pics with card out of plastic case? Paranoid I would do something stupid like bump a corner, drop it, cat would jump on photo table.....
I have entered some results below

Date Price Grade Lot # Auction House Auction/Seller Type Cert
5/6/2023 $61,909.20 9 75 Memory Lane, Inc. Spring '23 Rarities Auction Auction 07074888
5/10/2021 $31,200.00 9 80478 Heritage Auctions Spring Sports Catalog Auction - Dallas Auction 27229229
7/15/2020 $10,800.00 9 143649682443 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 07074888
1/13/2020 $13,780.80 9 231 Memory Lane, Inc. Winter Classic 2019 Auction 07074888
4/6/2019 $11,982.00 9 125 Memory Lane, Inc. Spring Break Rarities Auction 2019 Auction 42129922
4/11/2018 $12,100.00 9 142742005208 eBay pwcc_auctions Auction 50003702
10/14/2017 $9,002.40 9 14 Memory Lane, Inc. Fall Classic 2017 Auction Auction 50003702
8/12/2017 $11,395.20 9 76 Memory Lane, Inc. Sizzling Summer Auction 2017 Auction 27229229
4/23/2010 $6,572.50 9 81214 Heritage Auctions 2010 April Signature Sports Memorabilia Auction Ap Auction 01069895
11/8/2008 $6,642.28 9 266 Goodwin and Co. Auctions Masterpieces and Uncommon Commons XIX Auction 01069895
4/29/2005 $8,418.00 9 79 Memory Lane, Inc. The Buried Treasure II Card & Memorabilia Auction Auction 12141659

Share this item
loading...
{[currentAmount|currency]}
{[item.bid_count]} bid bids
{[$parent.item.starting_price|currency]}
{[item.bid_count]} bid bids
{[item.buynow_price|currency]}
Reserve price not met

  PurchasedWon by {[$parent.bidMemberName]}.

  Item Sold

Your invoice is being generated. Refresh to view.

Congratulations! You've won the auction.

Bennett & Roelofs Estate Service LLC should contact you within the next few days to finalize your transaction.

Item ended unsold.

Pending...
You were outbid. Better luck next time!
Other people want this item. {[item.follow_count]} person ispeople are following it.

Bidding Ended on Bidding Ends on {[bin_date|relative_date:"MMM DD hh:mma":false]} Sep 7, 7:30PM US/Central

Quantity Available Sold:
{[item.quantity]}
Buy It Now Price:
{[item.buynow_price_discount|currency]}
Discount:
{[item.discount]}%
Ending Price:
{[currentAmount|currency]}
High Bidder:
You *** private *** {[$parent.bidMemberName]}
Your Max Bid:
{[$parent.myMaxBid|currency]}
Shipping:
Local pickup only

Sun Prairie, WI 53590

Confirm Your Bid Buy it Now Matching High Bid Alert
Another bidder has placed a bid on this item just now

The minimum bid for this item may have changed as a result of recent bidding activity. Please close this window and select your max bid again.

This item is no longer available for bidding

This item is not available for bidding due to recent activity. This could be caused by the auction having just ended, another bidder using the "Buy It Now" option, or the seller removing the item.

Your maximum bid of exactly matches the maximum bid of the highest bidder. Since our system doesn't allow two matching high bids, you need to bid at least to become the high bidder. Would you like to bid that amount now?

What will happen:

Your max bid will be entered as and the high bid will be .

Your current max bid of will remain unchanged .

What will happen:

Your max bid will be increased to and you'll become the current high bidder.

Please confirm your maximum bid of {[bidAmount|currency]} which is the maximum you are willing to pay for this item. This amount is not visible to anyone but yourself and will only be used as needed to outbid other bidders and win the item at the lowest possible cost to you. If your maximum bid meets or beats the reserve, your bid will automatically be set to the reserve price. Should you win the auction at your maximum bid, your total commitment, including the {[buyerFeePercent]}% buyers premium, would be {[bidTotal|currency]} plus applicable taxes and fees. You are purchasing {[quantity]} of these itemsthis item for {[buyNowAmount|currency]} each. Your total commitment, including the {[buyerFeePercent]}% buyers premium, will be {[buyNowTotal|currency]} plus applicable taxes and fees.

Local Pickup Only - Sun Prairie, WI
Please indicate that you understand the local pickup only policy of this item by checking the box above By bidding, you agree to pick this item up in Sun Prairie, WI

You've bid on this item multiple times

We don't recommend constantly monitoring auctions to see if you've been outbid and then placing a new, higher bid each time. This may lead to you missing an opportunity to counter bid and losing the auction. Increase your chances of winning this auction by learning how our max bid system works.

 

By placing a bid, you agree to our Terms of Use.

Follow Bennett & Roelofs Estate Service LLC
Craigslist Code

Please note that Craigslist has stopped allowing external images as well as most html tags in their "for sale" listings. Your template will still have a full link to your sale and your sale photo gallery.

Preview your Craigslist template

  1. Go to Craigslist and find your city.
  2. Under For Sale, click on the Garage Sale category.
  3. Click on the Post link in the upper right corner of the page.
  4. Choose the Garage Sale category and then select your area. Craigslist doesn't have an Estate Sale category and this is the closest match.
  5. Add the title of your sale and the location.
  6. Add your email address and keep it anonymous to prevent spam.
  7. Copy & Paste the html code below into the Posting Description text box.
  8. Click Continue to add photos and publish your sale. You will receive a confirmation email from Craigslist to verify the sale. Activate your sale by clicking the link in your email and your done!
  9. Craigslist allows you to re-post your ad every 48 hours. Re-post any sooner and your ad may be subject to removal.
Create an account

Tell us what you'd like to do:

Have an existing account? Sign In